Mark/mesh-seed

Fork 0

INFRA-016: Create missing critical documentation files #113

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-10 01:02:23 +00:00 by Mark · 1 comment

Mark commented

2026-04-10 01:02:23 +00:00

Owner

Problem

Four critical documentation files are referenced throughout the codebase but do not exist, creating confusion and incomplete understanding of core systems.

Missing Files

CHAMPIONSHIPS.md - Referenced in docs/reference/FACTORY_PATTERN.md:305
- Purpose: Document championship competition system for variant evaluation
- Expected: Tournament structure, scoring metrics, winner determination
RUMINATION.md - Referenced in docs/reference/FACTORY_PATTERN.md:306
- Purpose: Document daily rumination process for promoting winners
- Expected: Promotion cycle, criteria, demotion process
CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md - Referenced in docs/reference/FACTORY_PATTERN.md:307
- Purpose: Document capability evolution lifecycle
- Expected: Factory to Nerve to Championship to Muscle flow
BONES.md - Referenced in docs/reference/TOOL_ARCHITECTURE.md:337
- Purpose: Document bone compilation and fast-path execution
- Expected: Compilation triggers, performance comparison, invalidation

Impact

Developer confusion - Referenced docs do not exist
Incomplete understanding - Core systems undocumented
Onboarding difficulty - New developers cannot find critical info
Architecture gaps - Cannot verify if implementation matches design

Scope (MINIMAL)

Create CHAMPIONSHIPS.md with tournament documentation
Create RUMINATION.md with promotion/demotion process
Create CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md with lifecycle documentation
Create BONES.md with compilation and execution details

Files

docs/reference/CHAMPIONSHIPS.md (new)
docs/reference/RUMINATION.md (new)
docs/reference/CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md (new)
docs/reference/BONES.md (new)

Acceptance Criteria

CHAMPIONSHIPS.md created with complete tournament documentation
RUMINATION.md created with promotion/demotion process
CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md created with lifecycle documentation
BONES.md created with compilation and execution details
All references validated and working

Blocks understanding of factory pattern
Related to Issue #104 (worker_factory bootstrap)

## Problem Four critical documentation files are referenced throughout the codebase but do not exist, creating confusion and incomplete understanding of core systems. ## Missing Files 1. **CHAMPIONSHIPS.md** - Referenced in docs/reference/FACTORY_PATTERN.md:305 - Purpose: Document championship competition system for variant evaluation - Expected: Tournament structure, scoring metrics, winner determination 2. **RUMINATION.md** - Referenced in docs/reference/FACTORY_PATTERN.md:306 - Purpose: Document daily rumination process for promoting winners - Expected: Promotion cycle, criteria, demotion process 3. **CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md** - Referenced in docs/reference/FACTORY_PATTERN.md:307 - Purpose: Document capability evolution lifecycle - Expected: Factory to Nerve to Championship to Muscle flow 4. **BONES.md** - Referenced in docs/reference/TOOL_ARCHITECTURE.md:337 - Purpose: Document bone compilation and fast-path execution - Expected: Compilation triggers, performance comparison, invalidation ## Impact - Developer confusion - Referenced docs do not exist - Incomplete understanding - Core systems undocumented - Onboarding difficulty - New developers cannot find critical info - Architecture gaps - Cannot verify if implementation matches design ## Scope (MINIMAL) 1. Create CHAMPIONSHIPS.md with tournament documentation 2. Create RUMINATION.md with promotion/demotion process 3. Create CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md with lifecycle documentation 4. Create BONES.md with compilation and execution details ## Files - docs/reference/CHAMPIONSHIPS.md (new) - docs/reference/RUMINATION.md (new) - docs/reference/CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md (new) - docs/reference/BONES.md (new) ## Acceptance Criteria - [ ] CHAMPIONSHIPS.md created with complete tournament documentation - [ ] RUMINATION.md created with promotion/demotion process - [ ] CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md created with lifecycle documentation - [ ] BONES.md created with compilation and execution details - [ ] All references validated and working ## Related - Blocks understanding of factory pattern - Related to Issue #104 (worker_factory bootstrap)

Mark referenced this issue

2026-04-10 01:02:41 +00:00

INFRA-001: Restore infrastructure proxy bidding subscription in mesh_node.py #98

Mark referenced this issue

2026-04-10 01:04:12 +00:00

INFRA-013: Deploy ValidationWorker + make workers actually run #110

Mark referenced this issue

2026-04-10 01:05:29 +00:00

INFRA-007: Add worker_factory to bootstrap workers #104

Mark referenced this issue

2026-04-13 02:44:27 +00:00

PRIMITIVE-002: Update FACTORY_PATTERN.md to reflect current state #207

Mark commented

2026-04-13 02:45:05 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cross-reference: This issue is now related to:

PRIMITIVE-001 (#206) - Define contract primitive type
PRIMITIVE-002 (#207) - Update FACTORY_PATTERN.md

The missing documentation files (CHAMPIONSHIPS.md, RUMINATION.md, CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md, BONES.md) are still needed, but the terminology refactoring has changed some context:

"Capability Evolution" should now be "Primitive Evolution"
References to capabilities/ paths need updating to primitives/

Priority: These docs are blocking developer understanding of the factory/championship/rumination system.

**Cross-reference:** This issue is now related to: - **PRIMITIVE-001 (#206)** - Define contract primitive type - **PRIMITIVE-002 (#207)** - Update FACTORY_PATTERN.md The missing documentation files (CHAMPIONSHIPS.md, RUMINATION.md, CAPABILITY_EVOLUTION.md, BONES.md) are still needed, but the terminology refactoring has changed some context: - "Capability Evolution" should now be "Primitive Evolution" - References to `capabilities/` paths need updating to `primitives/` **Priority:** These docs are blocking developer understanding of the factory/championship/rumination system.

Mark referenced this issue from a commit

2026-04-19 16:33:53 +00:00

docs: Update FACTORY_PATTERN.md to reflect 5 active factories

Mark added the

feature-request

label

2026-05-12 23:26:56 +00:00

Mark added the

triage-approved

quickfix

labels

2026-05-18 04:58:24 +00:00